Skip to content
OneSource Integration LLC

Winter closer season Cold slows closers and stiffens weatherstripping. A slamming door needs adjusting. More →

Selection

Choosing a closer, and why size is the last question.

Door weight and width set the size. Mounting position, exposure and code set almost everything else. Most closer complaints are a mounting or adjustment problem, not a product problem.

A door closer has one job and about six variables that decide whether it can do it. Get the variables right and the closer is invisible for fifteen years. Get them wrong and it becomes a permanent complaint that no amount of adjustment fixes.

Sizing: width first, weight second

ANSI/BHMA A156.4 defines closer sizes 1 through 6. Size is driven primarily by door width, with weight and exposure as modifiers.

Size Approx. door width Typical use
1up to 2'6"Light interior
2up to 3'0"Interior
3up to 3'6"Interior / light exterior
4up to 4'0"Exterior, standard commercial
5–6over 4'0"Wide or heavy exterior

Most commercial closers sold today are adjustable across a range — size 1 through 6, or 1 through 4 — set by a spring adjustment. That has made sizing less of a purchasing decision and more of an installation one, which is why so many doors in service are running at whatever size the closer shipped at.

The variables that actually decide it

  • Door width. Leverage. A wider door needs more spring power for the same closing force at the latch.
  • Door weight. A heavy wood or rated door needs more power than a hollow-core at the same width.
  • Exposure. An exterior door fighting wind or stack pressure needs more power than an interior one — and needs it in January as well as July.
  • Traffic. High cycle counts justify a heavier-duty body and better valving, regardless of size.
  • Code. ADA opening force and sweep timing, and positive latching on fire doors. These frequently pull in opposite directions and are where judgment comes in.
  • Mounting position. Which brings us to arms.

Arm types and mounting

Three standard mountings, and the choice is usually made by the door and frame rather than by preference.

Regular arm — closer on the pull side of the door, arm projecting out to the frame face. The most mechanically efficient of the three: it delivers the most closing power per unit of spring. The arm projects into the opening, which people walk into, and it looks the least tidy. Common on interior doors where efficiency matters more than appearance.

Parallel arm — closer on the push side, arm folded back parallel to the door face. The most common commercial mounting by a wide margin. The arm tucks out of the way, it's less vulnerable to abuse and vandalism, and it suits doors that open into corridors. The trade-off is efficiency: a parallel arm delivers meaningfully less closing power than a regular arm at the same size, so size up accordingly.

Top jamb — closer mounted on the frame face above the door, arm to the door. Used when there's no usable door face for the body, typically on aluminum storefront with a narrow top rail, or where the door is glass. Efficiency sits between the other two.

There's also concealed mounting — in the door, in the frame, or in the floor. It looks best, costs most, and is dramatically harder to service. On a historic or high-design elevation it's often the only acceptable answer.

When each manufacturer makes sense

LCN, Norton and Sargent all make closers that hold up for decades when they're sized, mounted and adjusted correctly. The differences are practical.

  • LCN — the default for heavy-duty and institutional work. The 4040XP and 4110 series are the closers you find still running after thirty years in schools and hospitals. Heavy, serviceable, and the benchmark for abuse resistance. Specify these where traffic is punishing.
  • Norton — strong across the middle of the market, with a deep range and good availability. The 1600 and 7500 series cover most standard commercial work, and the price/performance is hard to argue with on a large package.
  • Sargent — a natural fit where the rest of the opening is already Sargent, particularly on integrated hardware packages and where keying and exit devices are coming from the same source. Consistency across an opening has real value in service terms.

The more important decision is almost never the brand. It's whether the closer is mounted correctly, sized for the arm type, and adjusted after installation.

Code requirements to check before ordering

  • ADA opening force: 5 pounds maximum on interior doors, measured at the latch stile.
  • ADA sweep period: at least 5 seconds from 90 degrees to 12 degrees.
  • Fire doors: must close and latch positively from any open position. If the assembly is rated, the closer can't be disconnected, and hold-open is only acceptable on a device that releases on alarm.
  • Delayed action is a useful feature on accessible entrances and isn't the same thing as hold-open — it slows the first part of the swing rather than holding the door.

Why most closer complaints aren't the closer

Before replacing one, check in this order: is the door and frame square and are the hinges sound; is the strike aligned; is the closer the right size for its arm type; and has anybody ever adjusted the valves. In the field, a large majority of "bad closer" calls end at one of those four, and the closer goes back into service.

Need this applied to a real opening?

Reference material only goes so far. Tell me what the door is doing and what building it's in. A free 15-minute phone consult is often enough to tell what you're dealing with.